Five years ago, Elliot’s love, Peter, went missing, leaving behind only a severed finger in a pool of blood. Now, Elliot lives with his best friend and Peter's twin, Jess. The two are platonic soulmates. They won’t pretend like life doesn’t suck—but that doesn’t mean they’re not going to go out, hook up with randoms, get their hopes up over strangers, and laugh their asses off along the way.

Though, Elliot and Jess still cling to a small hope that they’ll find out what happened to the missing third in their trio. Scarred from this trauma, Elliot swore he would never love again... That is, until he met Will. Gorgeous, sexy, charming, and seemingly the most perfect man in the world for Elliot. But when ghosts of the past start to reappear, Elliot and Jess are determined to find out if Elliot is being targeted – or if Peter is still alive.